Read and Critique Groups - Some Tips

by Nancy Sackheim

In "3 Common Critique Group Flaws" WriteByNight's David Duhr says, “Whether or not a specific critique group is right for you depends entirely on three things: the group’s format, the quality of its humans, and what you’re hoping to get out of it. “

 How will the group function?

Should you have a mission statement? How often will you meet and how long will each session be? Will you submit in advance or bring pages? Will there be a set schedule for submissions or will writers sign up in "first come, first serve" order prior to each meeting? Is there a time limit for reading or word count limit for submissions? Should a time limit be set for each person commenting to ensure that everyone's critique is heard? Will you make time for socializing or keep it strictly business? Will there be guidelines for removing a member?

 Membership requirements

Members should generally be at the same level. A mix of pros and beginners is likely not a recipe for success. Decide whether or not everyone in the group should be writing in the same genre.  Will you charge a membership fee or a per session fee? Membership fees often cover the costs of maintaining a website or paying for a meeting space or video service for online meetings. Fees can also encourage regular attendance and promptness.

 Keep it small

Keeping it small allows the writers to really get to know one another and form relationships. A smaller group also allows members to submit more often. Too small, however, and sessions can end up cancelled when more than a couple members are absent. Somewhere between four and eight members is often the sweet spot for read and critique groups.

 Feedback

Set general guidelines for providing feedback. Request the kind of feedback wanted each time you submit, otherwise you may be given line edits when you were looking for deeper commentary or vice versa. Have a moderator or facilitator who can manage time and keep the requested feedback on track. Tact and patience are essential. A sense of humor is a plus.

 Additional Resources

The 4 Hidden Dangers of Writing Groups by Jennie Nash

 15 Tips for Successful Writing Groups by Joe Massucci

 Anne R. Allen, Critique Groups: 6 Ways they May Hurt Your Writing…and 6 Ways they Can Help

Photo by Joao Tzanno on Unsplash